All-Time Cardinals QBs Ranked: Warner #1, Hart #2

Max Hall

#6 · Arizona Cardinals
Retired 1 Year In The NFL
🏆 First-team All-MW (2007)
Max's
HAIR
5.5
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Max Hall or the Cardinals?

Max Hall Legacy

HEYTC AI
Max Hall, the scrappy Mesa kid who transferred to BYU and etched his name as the Cougars' winningest QB with 32 triumphs, lived for the clutch dagger—none bigger than that 4th-and-18 bomb to Austin Collie against hated Utah, or the OT strike to Andrew George that sent LaVell Edwards Stadium into frenzy. His rocket arm stunned No. 3 Oklahoma in the '09 opener, proving he could sling it with the best when the lights burned brightest. Brief NFL and CFL stints with the Cardinals and Bombers followed, but Provo's his forever home, now coaching high school titles while chasing that BYU degree. Pure competitor, Cougar legend.

Max Hall Rating Breakdown

Season
Non-Factor
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
1 year with the Cardinals

Max Hall Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
1 Touchdowns
6 INTs
39.0% Comp %
5.5 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Max Hall

How does Kyler Murray compare to Max Hall?

Kyler Murray towers over Max Hall like a Ferrari next to a golf cart—Kyler's diced up 15,000+ yards and 100 TDs as the Cards' dynamo, while Hall's "legacy" is a gritty three starts in 2010, 370 yards, one TD to Fitz, and a 35.7 rating that screams emergency filler. Hall shocked the Saints once; Murray owns Sundays.

Is Max Hall in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Max Hall's not chilling in Canton—no bust, no gold jacket, just a cup of coffee with the 2010 Cardinals where he chucked one TD amid six picks. Hall of Fame's for ring-chasers and stats monsters; Hall's the ultimate trivia answer for BYU fans nursing that Saints upset memory.

What is Max Hall doing now in 2026?

By 2026, Max Hall's traded pigskin for podcasts and pads—coaching high school ball in Arizona, dipping into broadcasting gigs, and running quarterback camps that sharpen the next Mesa kid. No headlines, just steady post-NFL hustle, far from those Winnipeg frosts or Cards chaos.

How would Max Hall perform in today's NFL?

Hall's quick release and gunslinger arm might snag a backup spot today with pass-happy rules—no more 14 sacks in six games—but that 50% completion and pick-six habit? Modern defenses would feast. Think undrafted journeyman like a 2010s Case Keenum lite, starting maybe twice before the clipboard calls.

How does Max Hall compare to Jim Hart?

Jim Hart lapped Max Hall like a marathoner passing a sprinter—Hart's 34.49 rating over 18 Cards years with 24,000 yards dwarfs Hall's 5.45 disaster (wait, 35.7 actual) in three starts. Hart was franchise bedrock; Hall, a 2010 panic button after Warner bolted. Both locals, worlds apart.