All-Time Giants QBs Ranked: Manning #1, Simms #2

Randy Dean

#15 · New York Giants
Retired 3 Years In The NFL
Randy's
HAIR
6.7
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Randy Dean or the Giants?

Randy Dean Legacy

HEYTC AI
Randy Dean, the Milwaukee kid who starred as Northwestern's gunslinging two-year starter in the brutal Big Ten, embodied the grit of '70s football—a quarterback who doubled as the Wildcats' best punter, booming kicks that still rank in school lore with a 42.5-yard average in '75. Drafted by the Giants in '77, he flashed promise amid the chaos of three up-and-down seasons before a Packers cameo ended his NFL ride. No spotlight hog, Dean's real legacy? Proving you could hang with legends like Otto Graham as a scholar-athlete in the National Football Foundation Hall, then thriving in business post-gridiron.

Randy Dean Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
3 years with the Giants

Randy Dean Career Stats via Wikipedia

0 Pass Yards
1 Touchdowns
5 INTs
0.0% Comp %
6.7 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Randy Dean

How does Jaxson Dart compare to Randy Dean?

Jaxson Dart's got the Giants' starting gig now, lighting up scoreboards in a pass-happy league, while Randy Dean's "legacy" boils down to 279 yards, one TD, and three starts across '77-'79—think emergency brake, not franchise driver. Dart's living the dream Dean glimpsed; it's like comparing a Ferrari to a '78 Pinto with a flat tire.

Is Randy Dean in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Randy Dean's not in Canton—his Giants stint was a blink: 279 yards, one TD pass, three starts total. Hall voters dream bigger than that cup-of-coffee cameo from the disco era. He's got a college punting nod, but Pro Football immortality? Not even on the ballot.

What is Randy Dean doing now in 2026?

No fresh intel on Randy Dean in 2026—he faded after the Giants cut him in '80, no broadcasts, businesses, or charity headlines popping. Probably kicking back somewhere, maybe reminiscing about that lone TD toss or his Dayon college punts. Guy's a ghost in the modern NFL radar.

How would Randy Dean perform in today's NFL?

Dean's scrambler style from the run-first '70s might snag a few gadget plays today, but his 30-of-65, 279-yard career screams backup at best—modern rules juice passers with protection and rules, yet he'd be Eli's emergency phone-a-friend, not a starter in this air-raid circus.

How does Randy Dean compare to Eli Manning?

Eli Manning owned the Giants' soul with two rings and an 84.1 rating peak; Randy Dean? A 6.69 passer rating on 279 yards and one TD across three forgettable years. Both blue-collar Giants QBs, but Eli's the meatball hero, Dean's the side of fries nobody remembers ordering.