Spergon Wynn

McCarthy's got the luxury Wynn never had—a competent supporting cast and a coaching staff that didn't treat him like a practice squad afterthought. McCarthy's a genuine prospect with arm talent; Wynn was a sixth-round developmental guy who never got the runway. McCarthy will likely have a real NFL career. Wynn's Vikings tenure was basically a cautionary tale.

Nope, Wynn never sniffed Canton, and frankly, his résumé wouldn't warrant serious consideration. He threw for 4,629 yards across multiple leagues with 26 touchdowns and 21 interceptions—solid journeyman numbers, nothing more. His most memorable Vikings moment was one of the worst quarterback performances since 2000.

Wynn's moved on to the business side, working as an energy broker with Amerex Energy Services in Houston, Texas. He's got two sons, Spergon IV and Slaton, and appears to have left football entirely in his rearview. No broadcasting gigs or coaching—just a clean exit to the private sector.

Modern rules wouldn't save Wynn. The passing game's evolved, but so has quarterback talent. He'd still be a backup at best, maybe a practice squad guy in a developmental program. His career EPA numbers were historically dreadful—even today's rule changes can't overcome that kind of fundamental inefficiency.

This isn't even close. Tarkenton was a Hall of Famer with 47,003 passing yards and genuine dual-threat brilliance; Wynn was a placeholder who posted minus-0.37 EPA per play over his Vikings stint. Tarkenton defined an era. Wynn defined disappointment.