All-Time Packers QBs Ranked: Starr #1, Rodgers #2

Tobin Rote

Retired 12 Years In The NFL
🏆 NFL champion (1957)
Tobin's
HAIR
14.8
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Tobin Rote or the Packers?

Tobin Rote Legacy

HEYTC AI
Tobin Rote was the ultimate gridiron gunslinger-scrambler, a Texas-bred rocket arm who terrorized defenses from Green Bay to San Diego, proving QBs could win with legs as much as lobs. Picture this: 1957 Lions playoff rout of the Browns, 59-14, Rote carving 'em up for 280 yards and four TDs before rumbling in one himself—one of history's wildest performances. Or '56 with the Pack, dropping 29 total scores in a 12-game blur. The only signal-caller to snag both an NFL crown (Lions) and AFL title (Chargers MVP), he even lit up the CFL like fireworks. Rote passed in 2000 at 72, his dual-threat legacy forever underrated.
Tobin Rote passed away on June 27, 2000 at the age of 72.

Tobin Rote Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Subpar
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
7 years with the Packers

Tobin Rote Career Stats via Wikipedia

18,850 Pass Yards
148 Touchdowns
191 INTs
0.0% Comp %
14.8 HAIR
48-64 Record

Frequently Asked Questions About Tobin Rote

How does Jordan Love compare to Tobin Rote?

Jordan Love's got the arm and the spotlight as Green Bay's current gunslinger, but Tobin Rote's the ultimate Packer trailblazer—racking up 18,850 yards and 148 TDs while leading the NFL in passing in '56 on a dismal 4-8 squad, plus torching foes with 3,128 rushing yards. Love's chasing that dual-threat ghost, but Rote's raw grit set the bar high before Lombardi rolled in.

Is Tobin Rote in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Tobin Rote never made it to Canton, despite a wild ride: NFL leader in passing yards and TDs in 1956, a 59-14 playoff demolition of the Browns with him slinging four scores and rumbling for another, plus an AFL title with San Diego. Packers Hall in '74, sure, but the big bronze bust? Still waiting.

How would Tobin Rote perform in today's NFL?

Rote would feast in today's pass-happy NFL—imagine his 1956 league-leading 2,700+ yards and 18 TDs, plus 11 rushing scores, under rules shielding QBs and banning the old leather helmets. That 150-yard rushing game against the Bears? He'd be a Mahomes prototype, scampering for chunk plays while bombing it deep.

How does Tobin Rote compare to Bart Starr?

Rote was the brawling gunslinger with a 14.84 rating, topping the Packers in TDs and rushing three times, while Bart Starr was the cool clinician at 64.74, mastering Lombardi's precision machine for five titles. Rote carried bad teams; Starr elevated a dynasty—two eras, same cheesehead blood, but Starr's rings steal the shine.