All-Time Giants QBs Ranked: Manning #1, Simms #2

Tommy DeVito

#16 · New York Giants
Retired 2 Years In The NFL
🏆 | undraftedyear = 2023
Tommy's
HAIR
10.6
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Tommy DeVito or the Giants?

Tommy DeVito Legacy

HEYTC AI
Tommy DeVito, the Livingston, N.J., kid with the slicked-back hair and old-school Italian swagger, crashed the NFL like a Sopranos extra at a Giants tailgate. Undrafted out of Syracuse and Illinois, he seized New York's QB chaos in 2023, winning three straight starts—including a gritty upset over these very Patriots—while getting sacked a absurd nine times in victory, toughest since '92. "Cutlets" became a meme, a folk hero, before bouncing to New England as their backup insurance policy. At 27, this 6-2 scrapper's legacy? Pure underdog poetry: proof you don't need pedigree to steal the spotlight in Big Blue's circus.

Tommy DeVito Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Good
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
2 years with the Giants

Tommy DeVito Career Stats via Wikipedia

1,358 Pass Yards
8 Touchdowns
3 INTs
65.3% Comp %
10.6 HAIR
3-5 Record

Frequently Asked Questions About Tommy DeVito

How does Jaxson Dart compare to Tommy DeVito?

Jaxson Dart's got the Giants' starting gig now, but Tommy DeVito's the one with the real New York fairy tale—those three straight wins in '23, mobbed by helicopters at his pizzeria, 1,358 yards and 8 TDs in 12 games as an undrafted Italian kid. Dart's unproven; Tommy's got that 4-8 grit, sitting at #24 on HeyTC's All-Time list for cult heroes who briefly owned the Meadowlands.

Is Tommy DeVito in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nah, Tommy DeVito's not in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no bronze bust in Canton for the pizza-slinging savior. His Giants stint was a wild '23 sparkler: 1,101 yards, 8 TDs, but a 4-8 record and quick fade to waivers. Hall's for two-time Super Bowl saviors like Eli, not one-hit wonders who got the city singing "That's Amore."

What is Tommy DeVito doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Tommy DeVito's on the Patriots roster after the Giants cut him loose, but he's DNP all '25 with New England—no snaps in their 13-3 division romp. Think backup life: practice reps behind whoever's slinging it in Foxboro, maybe some broadcasting side hustle or pizzeria promos, keeping that Jersey swagger alive without the starting chaos.

How would Tommy DeVito perform in today's NFL?

Tommy's quick release and Rutgers moxie would eat up today's pass-happy rules—no more mugging QBs, more YAC for his 64% completion and 6.2 yards per pop. That '23 stretch with 8 TDs in 9 starts? He'd carve backup minutes into spot starts, like a poor man's Geno Smith—mobile enough, scrappy, but needs protection to not get buried under 37 sacks again.

How does Tommy DeVito compare to Eli Manning?

Eli Manning's the Giants' desert eagle—84,895 yards, two Lombardi escapes, 59.81 rating—while Tommy's a 10.59 sparkplug in 12 games, 1,358 yards, same 8 TDs but a 4-8 skid. Eli owned primetime; DeVito owned Italian delis. Both franchise flavor, but Tommy's the appetizer before the two-time champ feast.