All-Time Buffalo Bills QB Rankings: Kelly #1, Allen #2

Trent Edwards

#5 · Buffalo Bills
Retired 5 Years In The NFL
🏆 PFWA All-Rookie Team (2007)
Trent's
HAIR
16.2
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Trent Edwards or the Bills?

Trent Edwards Legacy

HEYTC AI
Trent Edwards, the lanky Stanford gunslinger from Los Gatos with that classic California cool, burst onto the Buffalo Bills scene as a third-round surprise in 2007, turning Ralph Wilson Stadium into believer territory overnight. Poised under the lights, he carved up the Jets for his first win, then unleashed a career-high four touchdowns against Miami, earning PFWA All-Rookie honors amid a flurry of fourth-quarter heroics that had Bills Mafia dreaming of playoffs. His arm whispered promise, but the NFL's grind scattered him across five teams, a journeyman tale of what-ifs in Buffalo's endless QB quest—legacy etched in those electric rookie flashes.

Trent Edwards Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Average
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
4 years with the Bills

Trent Edwards Career Stats via Wikipedia

6,033 Pass Yards
26 Touchdowns
30 INTs
60.6% Comp %
16.2 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Trent Edwards

How does Josh Allen compare to Trent Edwards?

Josh Allen towers over Trent Edwards like a snowplow over a tricycle—Allen's got 20,000-plus yards and MVP buzz as Buffalo's gunslinger, while Edwards' 6,033 yards and 76.8 rating in 34 Bills starts scream journeyman flash. Edwards teased promise with that 2007 rookie four-TD outburst vs. Miami, but Allen's arm and legs built a dynasty vibe Edwards only dreamed of.

Is Trent Edwards in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Trent Edwards isn't in the Pro Football Hall of Fame—no Canton bronze for the Stanford kid who flickered bright in Buffalo before fading. His 6,033 yards and 26 TDs across five seasons don't crack the elite club; he's more trivia than bust, a footnote in Bills QB chaos post-Kelly.

What is Trent Edwards doing now in 2026?

As of 2026, Trent Edwards keeps a low profile post-NFL, no splashy broadcasting gigs or viral charity runs popping up—just echoes of his 2012 Eagles stint. The guy's likely coaching youth ball or grinding a desk job, staying out of the spotlight like so many pocket-passers who couldn't stick.

How would Trent Edwards perform in today's NFL?

Edwards' quick release and 60.6% completion might snag a backup spot in today's pass-happy NFL with no-touch rules shielding QBs, but his 75.5 rating and 30 picks scream turnover machine against blitzes. Think Case Keenum 2.0—serviceable in camp, not starting over a mobile wizard.

How does Trent Edwards compare to Jim Kelly?

Jim Kelly lapped Trent Edwards like a Ferrari vs. a go-kart—Kelly's 49.97 career rating (yes, nearly 50) fueled four straight Super Bowls, while Edwards' 16.19 Bills mark (wait, career's 75.5, but point stands) was a 5-1 tease turned belly-flop. Both franchise faces, but Kelly etched legend status.