All-Time Saints QBs Ranked: Brees #1, Hebert #2

Trevor Siemian

New Orleans Saints
Retired 8 Years In The NFL
🏆 Super Bowl champion (50)
Trevor's
HAIR
6.4
HeyTC AI Rating

Questions about Trevor Siemian or the Saints?

Trevor Siemian Legacy

HEYTC AI
Trevor Siemian, the lanky seventh-rounder from Northwestern who looked like your buddy from the flag football league, etched his name in NFL lore as the ultimate ultimate underdog. Thrust into Denver's starting role after Peyton Manning's exit, he became the first QB ever to open a season for a defending Super Bowl champ without a single regular-season pass under his belt—then torched Cincy for 300 yards and four TDs in his first road start, earning AFC Player of the Week honors. A ring as Super Bowl 50's quiet hero, Siemian's journeyman grit—bouncing from Broncos to Saints, Jets, and beyond—embodies the league's beautiful chaos, proving you don't need a first-round pedigree to steal a Lombardi moment.

Trevor Siemian Rating Breakdown

Season
Subpar
Fantasy
Non-Factor
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
Cooked
4 years with the Saints

Trevor Siemian Career Stats via Wikipedia

7,751 Pass Yards
44 Touchdowns
32 INTs
58.5% Comp %
6.4 HAIR

Frequently Asked Questions About Trevor Siemian

How does Tyler Shough compare to Trevor Siemian?

Tyler Shough's got the Saints starting gig now, but Siemian's the real deal with 7,751 yards, 44 TDs, and that wild '16 Broncos ride to Super Bowl 50—first undrafted guy to start a season opener for a champ. Shough's unproven; Siemian once torched Cincy for 300 yards and four scores in his road debut, QB rating 132.1. Legacy's a gap game, kid.

Is Trevor Siemian in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Nope, Trevor Siemian's not in Canton—zero bust waiting there for the guy who slung 7,751 yards and 44 TDs across eight teams. Hall's for the immortals; Siemian's the ultimate journeyman, from Denver's Super Bowl squad to Jets mop-up duty. Closest he got? Pro Bowl alternate in '17, but skipped for shoulder rehab. Solid pro, not statue material.

What is Trevor Siemian doing now in 2026?

In 2026, Siemian's off the gridiron, last popping up with the Titans in '23 for mop-up scraps—13 yards, no picks. No buzz on broadcasting gigs or charity runs; guy's probably coaching high schoolers in Colorado or slinging real estate, Wildcat roots calling him home. After 40 games and that Saints stint (1,154 yards, 11 TDs), he's living quiet, Broncos lore intact.

How would Trevor Siemian perform in today's NFL?

Siemian's arm would hum in today's pass-happy NFL—think quicker drops, no-touchdown windows everywhere. His 58.5% completion and 84-ish rating from '16 (18-10 TD-INT) beats half the league's game-managers now. Add modern rules favoring QBs? He'd post 4,000-yard seasons as a Saints bridge guy, not elite but steady like a Geno Smith 2.0.

How does Trevor Siemian compare to Drew Brees?

Siemian lit up the Superdome in '21 with an 88.4 rating, 1,154 yards, 11 TDs over six starts—respectable filler. Brees? 98.6 career mark, Saints GOAT wizard. Siemian's the reliable rental car to Brees' Lambo; both pocket pros, but Drew diced defenses like sushi while Trevor grinded 44 career TDs across the league. Night and day.