All-Time Saints QBs Ranked: Brees #1, Hebert #2

Tyler Shough

Starter 1 Year
2,384 Pass Yds
10 TDs
6 INTs
13 Total TDs
Tyler's
HAIR
18.0
HeyTC AI Rating
#32 Active

Questions about Tyler Shough or the Saints?

Tyler Shough Today

HEYTC AI
Tyler Shough's Saints fell 34-26 in their playoff elimination game, ending a rollercoaster 6-11 regular season where the rookie took over midseason from Week 8, posting 221-of-327 for 2,384 yards, 10 TDs, six INTs, and three rushing scores while going 5-4 as a starter to spark a late turnaround. In the loss, specific stats remain sparse, but Shough's arm and mobility shone in prior wins like his 333-yard, two-TD gem against the Titans, fueling buzz as HeyTC's #32-ranked quarterback overall. Post-game, fans and analysts hail him for carrying a thin receiving corps beyond Chris Olave, with the Saints committing to him as their 2026 starter amid Offensive Rookie of the Year chatter despite long odds. Offseason eyes turn to bolstering weapons around Shough to build on his gritty debut year.

Tyler Shough Rating Breakdown

Season
Average
Fantasy
Average
Playoffs
Non-Factor
Overall
NPC
1 year with the Saints

Tyler Shough Contract & Salary

Status Unknown

Tyler Shough 2025 Stats via ESPN

2,384 Pass Yards
10 Pass TDs
6 INTs
67.6% Comp %
18.0 HAIR
91.3 Passer Rtg
7.3 Y/A
11 Games
186 Rush Yards
3 Rush TDs

Should I Keep Tyler Shough?

HEYTC AI
KEEP 6/10 Confidence (Medium)

Tyler Shough flashed promise late in 2025, closing the year with a four‑game winning streak on a thin supporting cast and giving the Saints enough confidence to treat quarterback as “settled for now.” He profiles more as a speculative upside QB2 in dynasty than an immediate fantasy starter, dependent on New Orleans successfully upgrading weapons around him in 2026.

Tyler Shough Fantasy Projections & Matchup Analysis
QB27 Dynasty Rank
25 Age
4-6 years Elite Years Left
Low Trade Value
Career Trajectory: Rising

Only keep Shough if his cost is very cheap (late rounds or deep-roster dynasty) and your alternatives are replacement-level; at any meaningful draft-round premium he is not worth the slot given his unproven fantasy ceiling and current low ranking (#27 overall, 0 fantasy rating). In shallow keeper formats, he should be treated as a streaming-level asset rather than a core keeper.

Team Situation

The Saints finished 2025 at 6-11 and missed the playoffs, but team leadership publicly views quarterback as settled and plans to build around Shough with added pass-catching talent in 2026. That gives him short- to medium-term job security, though overall offensive upside still depends on how well New Orleans addresses its skill-position and special-teams weaknesses.

Long-term Factors
  • Late-season breakout and four-game win streak in 2025 created internal optimism and likely job security entering 2026.
  • Saints are actively expected to add pass catchers via the draft (including at No. 8 overall) and free agency to support Shough’s development.
  • Organizational messaging suggests QB is not an immediate need, but Shough still must prove consistency and efficiency to avoid future competition.

Tyler Shough Career Timeline

HEYTC AI
2026 2

Saints commit to Shough as 2026 starter

Ahead of the 2026 season, New Orleans publicly committed to Tyler Shough as the team’s starting quarterback, viewing him as a potential long-term answer at the position after he threw for 2,384 yards, 10 touchdowns, and added 3 rushing scores across his rookie year.

Earns NFL Offensive Rookie of the Month

For his performance late in the 2025 season, including his strong play in December and early January, Tyler Shough was named NFL Offensive Rookie of the Month, capping a breakout finish to his debut campaign.

2025 6

Sets Saints rookie QB records

Over the remainder of the 2025 season, Shough started for the Saints, setting the franchise record for wins by a rookie quarterback and becoming the first Saints rookie to throw for 300-plus passing yards in a game, which he achieved in Week 16 against the New York Jets.

First NFL start vs. Rams

Shough made his first NFL start in Week 9 of the 2025 season against the Los Angeles Rams, completing 15 of 24 passes for 176 yards with one touchdown and one interception in a 34–10 loss.

Named Saints starting quarterback

On October 28, 2025, with the Saints at 1–7, Kellen Moore named Tyler Shough the starting quarterback, setting him up to lead the offense for the remainder of his rookie season.

Makes NFL debut as backup for Saints

Shough made his first regular-season NFL appearance for the Saints in 2025, seeing limited action early in the season before being elevated later; he initially served as the backup while Spencer Rattler opened the year as the starter.

Enters Saints QB competition as rookie

Following Derek Carr’s post-draft retirement, Saints head coach Kellen Moore announced that rookie Tyler Shough would compete with Spencer Rattler and Jake Haener for the starting quarterback job during the 2025 offseason and training camp.

Drafted by New Orleans Saints

Tyler Shough was selected by the New Orleans Saints with the 40th overall pick in the second round of the 2025 NFL Draft after playing college football at Oregon, Texas Tech, and Louisville.

1 years in the NFL

Frequently Asked Questions About Tyler Shough

Is Tyler Shough injured?

No, Tyler Shough is not currently listed on the injury report. He completed the 2025 season healthy, including starting in Week 18 against the Atlanta Falcons on January 4, 2026. As the Saints head into the offseason, there are no reports of injuries affecting his availability.

How did Tyler Shough play in the last game of the 2025 season?

Tyler Shough started as quarterback for the Saints in their Week 18 game against the Atlanta Falcons on January 4, 2026. While specific box score stats are not detailed, he contributed to the team's strong late-season momentum after leading a 4-1 record in December and January.

Will Tyler Shough be traded by the Saints?

There are no current rumors indicating that Tyler Shough will be traded. Instead, reports focus on bolstering the offense around him, such as a potential dream trade for 49ers receiver Brandon Aiyuk to elevate his game in 2026.

What is Tyler Shough's current quarterback ranking?

Tyler Shough is currently ranked #32 on HeyTC's Daily AI Quarterback Rankings with an overall score in the NPC (18 tier). This places him outside the top 10 among NFL starting quarterbacks.[current data]

Who do the New Orleans Saints play next with Tyler Shough?

The Saints' 2025 regular season has concluded with no next game scheduled, as they did not qualify for the playoffs. Attention now shifts to the 2026 offseason, where Shough is positioned as the starting QB aiming to avoid a sophomore slump in a winnable NFC South.

What is the biggest current storyline for Tyler Shough?

The primary storyline is Tyler Shough's emergence as a potential franchise QB after leading the Saints to a 4-1 record in December and January of the 2025 season. Discussions center on avoiding a sophomore slump in 2026 and adding weapons like a dream trade for Brandon Aiyuk to build on this momentum.